Question:
Answer:
Yes, the devil can possibly deceive us into thinking we did something wrong when we didn’t, or into thinking we did something gravely wrong when we at best only committed venial sin (see CCC 1854-64).
Yet, as one priest has observed, we don’t want to give the devil too much credit. We have to recognize our own thought processes and how they may contribute to exacerbating our worries about sin. For example, we might suffer from scrupulosity, whether regarding a particular event or as a chronic cross we may have to periodically battle with at length (see Matt. 16:24-25), and which is in part a consequence of the fall (see CCC 395ff.).
Scrupulosity involves an obsessive concern with personal failings and an accompanying great difficulty to accept forgiveness, especially from God. It is a neurosis that encompasses seeing venial sin where this is actually no sin and mortal sin where there is at best venial sin or no sin at all. Those who experience scrupulosity struggle with a tortured conscience and an acute sense of inadequacy in the spiritual life, which robs them of the peace that God wants his children to have (John 14:27).
Consequently, for any person with concerns about the devil, or who may be dealing with scrupulosity as well, it’s important they have a regular priest confessor who can guide them in navigating their difficulties. No doubt the devil will try to exploit our weaknesses, but with God’s indispensable help, the guidance of a good priest confessor, our own efforts, and the support of family and friends, we can deal fruitfully with these challenges (Phil. 4:13; 2 Cor. 12:8-10).
In addition, if needed, a person with these struggles may also wish to consider getting other support from a licensed counselor who is respectful of your Catholic Faith.
Regarding counselors, we recommend you contact the Pastoral Solutions Institute, and Catholic Therapists.